Itâs Ben and Chris this week.
Nearly two years after a supposed EU green lobbying scandal made headlines across Europe, the evidence behind the original allegations is still⌠well, absent. Yet some MEPs are still pushing to restrict public funding for civil society. Funny how that works.
So, while this supposed scandal continues to distract attention from the very real costs of climate inaction (yes, COP gets a mentionâŚ), we take the opportunity to remind readers what civil society does, who it represents, and why we really canât do without it.
We also look at some major moments â and wins â for people and planet this week, including one of the largest protests in the history of independent Czechia, a landmark Supreme Court ruling in Norway against new oil drilling in the North Sea, and positive steps towards restricting PFAS pollution in Europe.
Enjoy the read, and if you do, consider buying us a coffee â If youâd like to get in touch, weâd love to hear from you at newleaf@eeb.org.
đ° THE GREAT GREEN SCANDAL THAT WASNâT
âRemember that joke about the green lobbying scandal in Brussels?â Thatâs how Mathijs Schiffers, Geopolitics and Geoeconomics Editor at Dutch financial newspaper Het Financieele Dagblad, introduced his latest article. Back in January 2025, De Telegraaf declared: âLobbying scandal in Brussels: EU secretly paid environmental groups to promote Timmermansâ green policies.â The newspaper claimed this was revealed by secret contracts it had obtained. The story became headline news across Europe, picked up by more than 200 media outlets. Nearly two years later, Het Financieele Dagblad now reports: âNo evidence of a âgreen lobbying scandalâ in Brussels.â Quite the plot twist.
Even the original headlines are changing. De Telegraaf itself now acknowledges that an EU Parliament scrutiny group, established by some conservative and far-right lawmakers, failed to find hard evidence that the Commission had instructed environmental organisations to lobby on its behalf.
From facts to perception. As Elena SĂĄnchez NicolĂĄs, editor-in-chief at the EUobserver, puts it: âAfter a year of scrutiny, the âgroupâ could not establish a single breach of rules.â Instead, the groupâs authors have shifted their arguments from alleged facts towards vague concerns about perceptions and reputational risks. Apparently, when the evidence doesnât cooperate, perceptions will have to do.
Democracy means disagreement. Despite all this, the group still recommends restricting funding for civil society organisations if they say and do things its members disagree with. But not everyone in Parliament is having it. In a united joint statement, representatives of S&D, Renew Europe, Greens/EFA and The Left called on the Commission to reject the recommendations in full â and on Parliament President Roberta Metsola to prevent the group from further damaging Parliamentâs reputation.
But the implications are serious. A healthy democracy needs independent voices, including those that challenge governments and powerful interests. As EEB Deputy Secretary-General Patrizia Heidegger reminds us: âIf we truly believe in European democracy, we need to support civil society not only when it agrees with those in power, but precisely when it doesnât.â
đŁď¸ WHOSE VOICE GETS HEARD?
Democracy by design. Thereâs a reason the EU has long supported civil society organisations. Back in 2001, the Commissionâs White Paper on European Governance recognised that the EUâs legitimacy depends on public participation. EU funding for environmental organisations was designed, in part, to enable them to contribute to policymaking, bring citizensâ concerns to the table and balance the interests of other actors. Today, dialogue with civil society is even enshrined in Article 11 of the EU Treaty.
Not all lobbying is the same. As Gina Romero, UN Special Rapporteur on the rights to freedom of peaceful assembly and of association, reminded us this week: âPublic interest advocacy and corporate lobbying are different things.â For organisations like the EEB, that means bringing peopleâs concerns and demands to policymakers, defending their rights and challenging policies that threaten our health and the nature we depend on. Both public-interest advocates and corporate lobbyists seek to influence policy, but the interests they represent and the resources at their disposal can be worlds apart.
An uneven playing field. While not-for-profit organisations face manufactured allegations and increasing scrutiny over their funding and advocacy, powerful corporate interests continue to enjoy privileged access to decision-makers. A recent Transparency International EU investigation found that at least two-thirds of the organisations invited to a key Commission roundtable on weakening corporate sustainability rules represented business interests, while just 13 of the 110 organisations were NGOs.
Accountability for all. Transparency and accountability should apply to everyone receiving EU funding â businesses and civil society organisations alike. And lobbying influence deserves scrutiny regardless of whose interests are being represented. Yet the current debate risks focusing on restricting independent public-interest advocacy rather than ensuring everyone has a meaningful voice in EU policymaking. As Romero also warns, arbitrary restrictions on civil society advocacy threaten the participation that EU democracy is supposed to protect.
đ THE PLANET IS SENDING INVOICES
Boiling point. This week, the European Environment Agency warned that the costs of climate inaction are climbing rapidly, threatening Europeâs economy, food production and long-term resilience. Yet despite Europe being the worldâs fastest-warming continent, fresh from a summer marked by devastating droughts, crop losses and wildfires, progress remains painfully slow. As COP31 in Antalya draws to a close, the question is not whether the climate crisis is accelerating, but why political action continues to lag so far behind the science.
Fox in the henhouse. One answer may be found in the conference halls. According to Kick Big Polluters Out, more than 100 corporations and industry associations representing fossil fuels, industrial meat and dairy, Big Tech and other major polluting sectors attended COP31 â all identified in its analysis as having records of obstructing or opposing stronger climate policies.
Grand Theft Planet. Once again, itâs not the Big Polluters who are paying the price. Itâs ordinary people who are being forced to foot the bill. Climate-related losses in Europe have reached âŹ270 billion in just the last five years, while the biggest fossil fuel companies continue to report tens of billions in profits. Pension funds are becoming more exposed to climate risks, while insurers warn that rising losses from floods, droughts and wildfires will make coverage increasingly expensive â or even unavailable.
Respect my (planetary) boundaries. We cannot ignore the science. Earth system scientist Johan RockstrĂśm warns that while net-zero is essential, it is no longer enough. Humanity has now exceeded seven of the nine planetary boundaries that define a safe operating space for human civilisation. His post-COP message to policymakers is to rapidly cut emissions, restore natureâs resilience, and scale up carbon removals. In short, the solutions are known. Governments just need to be willing to put long-term public interests ahead of short-term corporate lobbying pressure.
This is where civil society comes in. When powerful interests can invest millions in delaying change, independent civil society organisations play a vital democratic role. They help ensure that science, public interest and long-term resilience are not drowned out by those whose business models depend on exceeding planetary boundaries.
â FIGHTING THE GOOD FIGHT
A landmark win against new oil drilling. Norwayâs Supreme Court delivered a major victory this week by ruling that permits for three oil and gas fields in the North Sea were unlawfully granted and are invalid. The judgment reinforces the simple but powerful principle that governments must assess the climate consequences of major fossil fuel projects, including emissions from burning exported oil and gas abroad, and whether projects are compatible with their climate obligations. Brought by environmental organisations, the case also shows how civil society can use the courts to defend the public interest and hold governments accountable.
400,000 people defend independent media. Prague witnessed one of the largest demonstrations in its history this week, with an estimated 400,000 people taking to the streets in defence of independent public broadcasting and the right to reliable, publicly accessible information. At a time when disinformation is proliferating and democratic norms are being tested across Europe, the message from Greenpeace, which joined the protest, was clear: âPeople have the right to know whatâs going on.
âData centres face growing pushback. Across Europe, communities are challenging the rapid expansion of data centres over concerns about their impacts on water, energy consumption, land use and local quality of life. From residents worried about water shortages and rising electricity demand to campaigners highlighting environmental justice and human rights concerns linked to the âAI boomâ, opposition is growing rapidly.
đĄ ON OUR RADAR
PFAS: a major step closer to a ban. This week, the European Chemicals Agencyâs scientific committees backed an EU-wide restriction on âforever chemicalsâ, calling it the most effective way to tackle their risks. At the EEB, we welcome this outcome. The ball is now in the Commissionâs court. The development comes as the European Court of Auditors warns that EU action on PFAS remains too slow, with existing rules failing to adequately protect people and the environment.
Childrenâs health over Big Food profits. We joined a broad coalition of health organisations, academics and civil society groups this week calling on the Commission to strengthen protections against unhealthy food marketing to children. The coalition wants tougher rules across TV, streaming, social media and influencer content, alongside stronger safeguards in upcoming EU digital legislation. Childrenâs health should come before the commercial interests of food corporations.
Closing the gap on agricultural methane. Europe wants to cut methane emissions, but its agricultural subsidies tell a different story. Our new briefing, The Methane Trap, shows how the EUâs Common Agricultural Policy (CAP) continues to support emissions-intensive livestock farming while doing little to tackle methane pollution. With only 2.4% of EU farmed animals planned to be covered by relevant emissions measures, the gap between ambition and action is hard to ignore. With the post-2027 CAP on the table, Europe has a chance to change course â moving away from destructive business as usual and supporting farmers in building more sustainable food systems.
By: Ben Snelson, with Christian Skrivervik, Julianne van Pelt and Roi Gomez. Editor: Christian Skrivervik
đ§ Â DOPAMINE HIT
As ever, here are a few happy updates to get your weekend off to a perky start:
- Apple to face trial in France over planned obsolescence. Read more here
- Hope springs eternal in award-winning photos showcasing natureâs resilience.Read more here
- Nations promise to install more rooftop solar at UN climate talks. Read more here
- 30% Drop in Levels of Forever Chemicals in Englandâs Rivers, 49% in Fish â âBrilliant to Seeâ.Read more here
đ§ THE JOB FAIRY
- World Food Programme is looking for an External Relations Intern
- Zero Waste Europe is looking for a Zero Pollution Policy Manager
- Eurocities is looking for a Policy and Advocacy Intern
- European Climate Foundation is looking for a Senior Learning and Impact Independent Consultant
â BUY US A COFFEE
From dirty lobbies to smear campaigns, billionaire bullies to climate collapse, we face a lot. Support our work, one coffee at a time.
đ˘ ORGANISE
If you are not involved, get involved. Find a member organisation near you.
đ FOLLOW US
Stay connected with us on LinkedIn, Bluesky, TikTok, Instagram, and YouTube. Donât miss out!
Are you a journalist? Subscribe here to stay up to date on our latest European environmental policy updates made specifically for you!
We have opened a new mailbox for your tips and tales from the ground. Got something you think we should feature? Reach out to us at newleaf@eeb.org.
⨠SIGN UP
Stay informed. Subscribe to our Newsletter by email for the latest EU environmental updates every Friday morning and to support our work. By subscribing, you also get early access to our in-depth analysis of key EU environmental policy.
